Incogni vs Cloaked: Cleanup vs prevention

Incogni cleans up existing exposure by removing your data from brokers. Cloaked prevents future exposure with masked identities, and treats removals as a secondary feature. See how they stack up...

30-day money-back guarantee

At a glance

Incogni and Cloaked address different privacy needs, so data removal plays a different role in each service.

Incogni's strenth: removals

Incogni's strenth: removals

420+ brokers across many categories and 34 countries, with an independently verified removal rate.

Cloaked's strength: prevention

Cloaked's strength: prevention

A broader privacy bundle with data removal, aliases, password tools, call protection, and identity protection.

What to weigh

What to weigh

Choose based on whether you need existing data removed, new exposure limited, or both.

Individual plans, compared

Cloaked's price reflects its full prevention toolkit. Incogni's reflects deeper, dedicated removal.¹

Individual plans, compared

Incogni: Standard and Unlimited plans ¹

Both plans cover 420+ brokers: Standard at $7.99/mo, or Unlimited at $14.99/mo with custom removals added.

Cloaked: Individual plan ²

Individual costs $9.99/mo and lists 1,059 pages, including 379 classified broker entries.

What to consider

Incogni covers more brokers. Cloaked combines removal with aliases and privacy tools, but doesn’t offer custom removals.

Family and group plans

Incogni covers five people under a single plan with the full 420+ brokers. Cloaked's family tiers cover fewer people.¹

Family and group plans

Incogni: Family and Family Unlimited

At $15.99/mo, Incogni Family handles removals automatically. Unlimited costs $22.99/mo and adds custom requests.

Cloaked: Couple and Family plans

Every Cloaked plan shares one feature set—only headcount shifts. Couple is $14.99/mo, Family $24.99/mo for up to four.

What to consider

Incogni’s Family Unlimited plan adds custom removals. Cloaked includes removal and privacy tools but not custom removals.

How the removal engines compare

Both show removal status. The listed pages differ substantially in composition, and neither dashboard confirms every removal.

Incogni
Cloaked
Removal method
Automated requests, human-assisted if needed
Automated requests
Sites on the list
425
1,059 listed entries
Data-brokers pages
422
379 classified broker entries
Recurring scans and requests
Every 30-60 days
45-day automated cycle
Removal rate (after 30 days)
Not independently tested
Proof of removal
Live dashboard status per request
Live dashboard status per request
Get started

Where coverage differs

Cloaked lists 1,059 entries, but only 379 of them can be classified as data brokers.

First-party collectors on the list

First-party collectors on the list

Cloaked lists 676 first-party collectors, mostly corporate privacy pages, that are not data brokers.³

Range of broker types

Range of broker types

Incogni lists all six broker categories; Cloaked lists five, with no credit-reporting entries.

Brokers list composition

Brokers list composition

Both services cover similar number of people-search sites, but Incogni adds more marketing data brokers (107 vs 47).

Why the broker counts differ

Why the broker counts differ

Cloaked labels 354 entries “Data broker.” Our classification counts 379 across its full list.

Beyond removal: extras and bundles

Cloaked's biggest edge is prevention—its toolkit stops new exposure. Incogni bundles security and monitoring instead.

Incogni Protect

Combines Unlimited removal with Coveron: $1M insurance plus dark web and TransUnion monitoring. US only.

Incogni Protect

Surfshark One+

Pairs Incogni with a VPN, alternative ID, ad blocker, antivirus software, breach alerts, and up to $1M identity theft coverage.

Surfshark One+

Cloaked’s separate offerings

Cloaked has no separate consumer bundle to add to its standard privacy platform.

Cloaked’s separate offerings

Value for money and refund terms

Prices are calculated assuming annual billing. The cost per automated broker removal is calculated based on the actual, not the claimed, number of broker sites.

Incogni
Cloaked
Lowest individual price
$7.99/mo (Standard)
$9.99/mo (Individual)
Highest individual price
$14.99/mo (Unlimited)
$9.99/mo (Individual)
Cost per automated broker
~$0.02/mo (Standard)
~$0.03/mo (Individual)
Billing
Monthly and annual
Monthly and annual
Money-back/risk-free policy
30-day, money-back guarantee
30-day, money-back guarantee
Free trial
No free trial or free tier
No free trial or free tier
Get started

What Incogni users say (recurring topics)

Incogni has substantial feedback: 329 firsthand and organic reviews from Reddit and Trustpilot. ⁴

Direct comparisons from Reddit

4 Reddit users compared them; 3 used both. They cited Incogni’s broker reach or price and Cloaked’s extra name fields.

Listings users checked themselves

Nine Reddit users found their listings gone in their own searches. About 31 organic Trustpilot reviews mention less data online.

Reported outcomes differ

Across Reddit and Trustpilot, at least 97 users and reviews report changes in spam: 38 say it fell, while 59 say it rose.

What Cloaked users say (recurring topics)

Cloaked has a substantial footprint: 618 firsthand and organic reviews from Reddit and Trustpilot, but only 72 discuss removal.⁵

Removal works for many

Twenty-five Reddit users and Trustpilot reviewers (3 and 22) said Cloaked removed their data, often citing removal counts.

Removal credited for fewer calls

About 13 reviewers said they received fewer spam calls and credited Cloaked’s removal service.

Slower or thinner than expected

About 11 reviewers said removal was slow, covered less than expected, or made no difference to their spam.

Can you trust Incogni?

Incogni's removal claims are backed by both independent verification and a peer-reviewed test—rare in this industry.

Can you trust Incogni?

Study result

A 2025 independent study found that Incogni achieved a 76.6% removal rate, providing evidence of its effectiveness.

Data handling

Incogni has completed a SOC 2 Type 2 examination, which assesses controls for protecting and handling customer data over time.

Verified process claims

Deloitte verified Incogni's 420+ broker coverage, recurring requests, and 245 million-plus requests processed (as of July 2025).

Can you trust Cloaked?

Cloaked publishes a removal-site list and holds third-party credentials, but its removal effectiveness remains untested.

cloaked review

Published coverage list

Cloaked lists 1,059 entries, including 676 first-party collector sites. Its own “Data broker” tag covers 354 entries.

BBB accreditation and rating

Cloaked is BBB accredited but has a B rating. Its profile lists complaints filed against the business.

No independent test cited

Unlike Incogni, Cloaked has no independent removal test cited in this comparison.

So which one should you choose?

If you strip away the feature lists, the real choice is whether you need to clean up yesterday's exposure or prevent tomorrow's.

Incogni may suit you if...

Incogni may suit you if...

Your data is on broker sites, and you want broader, lower-cost removal than Cloaked across more countries, with verified claims.

Cloaked may suit you if...

Cloaked may suit you if...

Your priority is preventing new exposure with aliases, virtual numbers, a password manager, and identity theft insurance.

Weigh carefully

Weigh carefully

You want two security layers: Incogni helps remove what's already out there, then Cloaked keeps new information from spreading.

Get started in minutes

Protecting your personal information is simple and intuitive with Incogni.

Step 1

Step 1

Sign up

Create an account and provide basic information.

Step 2

Step 2

Give permissions

Grant us the right to legally send requests on your behalf with just a few clicks.

Step 3

Step 3

We get to work

We automatically identify and submit removal requests to data brokers.

Step 4

Step 4

Track progress

Monitor the data removal progress in real time and submit extra links via Custom Removals.

30-day money-back guarantee on all Incogni plans

If we don't meet your expectations, contact our 24/7 Customer Support Team within 30 days of signing up, and we'll refund the full amount paid.

1 All prices shown on this page are up to date as of 13 November, 2026, and are based on information published at https://incogni.com/pricing, assuming the purchase of an annual subscription. Data broker counts are based on the list published at https://blog.incogni.com/data-brokers-incogni-covers/, accessed 20 October, 2026.

2 Cloaked, “Data Removal,” accessed October 13, 2026, https://www.cloaked.com/features/data-removal. Broker counts are based on the list of covered sites on this page (1,059 entries, each labeled “Data broker” or “Other website” by Cloaked). First-party collectors and public sites are not counted as data brokers.

3 We used the CCPA definition. Under it, first-party collectors collect your data when you interact with them and may use tracking cookies to serve you ads. However, they are not legally classified as data brokers because they do not derive a legally defined threshold of their revenue from selling that data to third parties.

4 Based on 1,885 public comments and reviews about Incogni (814 Reddit posts and comments, Jan 2025 – Oct 2026; 1,071 US Trustpilot reviews, Jan 2025 – Oct 2026), after excluding affiliated, promotional, duplicate, and off-topic content. 82% of the reviews were company-invited.

5 Based on 843 public comments and reviews about Cloaked (212 Reddit posts and comments, Jan 2025 – Oct 2026; 631 US Trustpilot reviews, Oct 2025 – Oct 2026), after excluding affiliated, promotional, duplicate, and off-topic content.

Privacy PolicyCookie PolicyTerms of Service