Incogni vs LifeLock: How their data removal compares

Both remove data from brokers, but Incogni is built for broad, verified broker removal, while LifeLock tucks removal inside an identity-protection suite. See how they compare...

30-day money-back guarantee

At a glance

Incogni targets broad broker coverage, with identity protection as an add-on. LifeLock focuses on identity protection instead.

Incogni's strength: removals at scale

Incogni's strength: removals at scale

Coverage spans 420+ data brokers with unlimited custom removals, independently verified and available across 34 countries.

LifeLock's strength: identity protecton

LifeLock's strength: identity protecton

Two decades in identity protection: continuous monitoring, restoration support, and up to $1M in identity-theft insurance.

Making the call

Making the call

Choose Incogni for the broadest verified removal, or LifeLock for full identity-theft monitoring, recovery, and insurance.

Individual plans, compared

Both automate broker removal. LifeLock wraps it in an identity theft protection suite, but without custom removals.¹

Individual plans, compared

Incogni: Standard and Unlimited plans

Incogni Standard costs $7.99/mo and Unlimited is for $14.99/mo. Both cover 420+ brokers; Unlimited includes custom removals.

LifeLock: three individual plans

Core ($10.42/mo), Advanced ($16.67/mo), and Total ($29.17/mo) plans include automated data broker removals.

What to consider

Pick Incogni for the widest broker reach and custom/automated opt-outs or pair it with LifeLock for an identity protection layer.

Family and group plans

Incogni covers five people per plan. LifeLock lets you add up to seven adult or junior memberships, or pick its family plan.¹

Family and group plans

Incogni: Family and Family Unlimited

Incogni Family ($15.99/mo) includes automated removals from 420+ brokers. Unlimited ($22.99/mo) adds unlimited custom removals.

LifeLock: several options

Advanced is $30/mo for a couple or $40/mo for a couple plus up to nine children. Add up to seven children for $5.50/mo each.

What to consider

Pick Incogni for extensive data removal. Pick LifeLock for full identity protection that includes a basic removal tool.

How the removal engines compare

The re-scan cadence is similar, but that's where the similarities end. Incogni's removal effectiveness has been verified, and it also offers human support for more complex removal cases.

Incogni
Lifelock
Removal method
Automated requests, human-assisted if needed
Automated requests
Recurring scans and requests
Every 60 days (public brokers) / 90 days (private brokers)
Quarterly
Removal rate (after 30 days)
Not independently tested
Proof of removal
Live dashboard status per request
Live dashboard status per request
Get started

Where coverage differs

LifeLock presents no broker list, citing only "a collection of the biggest data brokers."²

Published list of pages

Published list of pages

Unlike LifeLock, Incogni keeps the list of covered sites public.

International coverage

International coverage

LifeLock is dedicated to US residents. Incogni is available in 34 countries.

Dark web monitoring

Dark web monitoring

It’s a standard LifeLock feature. Incogni offers it in a separate privacy bundle.

Beyond removal: extras and bundles

LifeLock sells monitoring, protection, removal, and insurance as one product. Incogni offers that through optional bundles.

Incogni Protect

Combines Unlimited removal with Coveron: $1M insurance plus dark web and TransUnion monitoring. US only.

Incogni Protect

Surfshark One+

Pairs Incogni with a VPN, alternative ID, ad blocker, antivirus software, breach alerts, and up to $1M identity theft coverage.

Surfshark One+

Norton’s cybersecurity tools

LifeLock is a bundle in itself, using many of Norton's features under one umbrella.

Norton’s cybersecurity tools

Value for money and refund terms

Prices are calculated assuming annual billing. The cost per automated broker removal is calculated based on the actual, not the claimed, number of covered brokers.

Incogni
Lifelock
Lowest individual price
$7.99/mo (Standard)
$10.42/mo
Highest individual price
$14.99/mo (Unlimited)
$29.17/mo
Cost per automated broker
~$0.02/mo (Standard)
— (number of brokers not disclosed)
Billing
Monthly and annual
Monthly and annual
Money-back/risk-free policy
30-day, money-back guarantee
60-day, money-back guarantee
Free trial
No free trial or free tier
30-day free trial
Get started

What Incogni users say

Users appreciate the hands-off process and continuous opt-out requests, though Incogni's dashboard lacks visual proof for some.

From 160+ broker sites down to 39

After trying manual removal, a Trustpilot user switched to Incogni. In six months, exposure dropped from 160+ sites to ~39.³

Catches brokers that re-list your data

A Trustpilot user credits Incogni for spotting sites that re-list data after removal and automatically resubmitting requests.⁴

Trust trade-off

Reddit users note the dashboard shows "completed" status but no screenshots or before/after evidence.⁵

What LifeLock users say

Users describe LifeLock's removal as basic, and point to notable price jumps when the first year ends.

Perceptions of limited coverage

Several users characterized LifeLock’s removal or monitoring coverage as limited.⁶

Only basic level of removals

A LifeLock user described its removal function as “the bare minimum.”⁷

Renewal prices jump 30–52% at year two

Reddit users flag big renewal hikes—Standard goes from ~$9 to $12/mo, Ultimate Plus from ~$17 to $28/mo.⁸

Why you can trust Incogni

Built on Surfshark's cybersecurity track record, and validated externally through Deloitte assurance and a SOC 2 examination.

Why you can trust Incogni

Deloitte ISAE 3000—first of its kind in the industry

Deloitte independently verified Incogni's broker coverage, recurring removals, deletion confirmations, and no data selling.⁹

Compliant across the US, EU, UK, and Canada

Leverages the GDPR, CCPA, and PIPEDA to legally compel broker deletion.

2,900+ Trustpilot reviews

One of the largest review bases among dedicated data removal services, with mostly 4- and 5-star reviews.

Can you trust LifeLock?

Two decades in identity protection, though BBB accreditation is missing and its parent has had past security incidents.

Can you trust LifeLock?

20+ years of brand recognition

LifeLock, founded in 2005, holds a 4.9-star average across 16,500+ Trustpilot

A+ BBB rating but not BBB Accredited

LifeLock holds an A+ BBB rating based on complaint resolution, but has not committed to BBB accreditation standards.

Parent company Gen Digital had credential-stuffing incident

Credential stuffing affected Norton Password Manager users. LifeLock wasn’t breached, but shares the same infrastructure.

So which one should you choose?

Start with your priority—the deepest verified broker removal, or full identity-theft monitoring and recovery.

Incogni may suit you if...

Incogni may suit you if...

You want effortless, broad data removal with verified results, extendable with identity protection features.

LifeLock may suit you if…

LifeLock may suit you if…

Your priority is identity-theft monitoring, restoration, and insurance, with basic data removal folded into the package.

..or use both

..or use both

Pair Incogni's removal depth with LifeLock's recovery tools. Alone, its removal is limited and renewal prices climb sharply.

Get started in minutes

Protecting your personal information is simple and intuitive with Incogni.

Step 1

Step 1

Sign up

Create an account and provide basic information.

Step 2

Step 2

Give permissions

Grant us the right to legally send requests on your behalf with just a few clicks.

Step 3

Step 3

We get to work

We automatically identify and submit removal requests to data brokers.

Step 4

Step 4

Track progress

Monitor the data removal progress in real time and submit extra links via Custom Removals.

30-day money-back guarantee on all Incogni plans

If we don't meet your expectations, contact our 24/7 Customer Support Team within 30 days of signing up, and we'll refund the full amount paid.

Privacy PolicyCookie PolicyTerms of Service